Email Marketing Automation Best Practices in 2023

Nurture campaigns with the goal to upsell

For your current customers, you may want to trigger email campaigns based off of whether they are a free subscriber or a paying one. For example, if a free user is using your product or service X amount of time a month for three months, an email can be triggered that suggests an upgrade by explaining the benefits of a paid plan to the user.

Anniversary emails

This is a simple way to make your user feel special. Consider sending them a special email with a discount or free gift that is triggered on the year after they sign up. Just make sure that the discount or gift can be redeemed with a week or two of wiggle room in case they aren’t checking their email all the time.

Onboarding and email signup automation

When someone signs up for your product/service, or even if they are just signing up to receive emails from your brand, automating this portion will help keep their attention and mind on your brand while saving you time so you can focus on acquiring more users. Looking for more information on creating a welcome email series? Check out The Welcome Email Series: Strategy And Benefits of A Layered Brand Introduction.

Re-engagement and sunsetting policies

One of the most crucial actions that influences your delivery rates is how well you remove unengaged users from your email list. A good rule of thumb is to remove a user as soon as 3 months go by without them opening your email. But before removing unengaged users, consider an automated campaign that asks recipients if they would prefer to receive email at a different cadence before you remove them from your email list for good.

Subscription expiration

When somebody’s subscription is about the expire, triggering an email with copy asking them to update or renew a couple of weeks ahead of time will save lost users who just forgot and let their membership or subscription lapse.

One of the more common goals of email automation is to increase recipient engagement. Not only do opens and clicks support achieving business goals like awareness and conversion, they also keep your email deliverability rates high too. But since no two email recipients are identical, they will need to be catered to depending on how they currently interact with your email.

The following example is simple, but illustrates the concept of automated email in action and provides the necessary framework for you to build off of as you customize it for your own program.

Consider a business that sends one promotional email campaign per month. You may want to start out with 3 paths for your customers:

Path 1: VIP offers to engaged users

The first path includes people who have clicked on 3 out of 3 of your last promotional email sends. Those users are prompted to a special VIP email that automatically sends a week after their last open with discounts or promotions for your product or service.

Path 2: Educational content to partially engaged users

The second path includes recipients who clicked on 1 of your 3 last promotional emails, but still haven’t signed up for anything yet. This person may or may not be interested in taking the next step with your brand, so sending more email right away may not be in your best interest.

After a couple weeks since their first open, consider sending an automated email that isn’t promotional, rather educational that may focus on the benefits of your service in general. Tip: spend extra time on crafting your subject line that will intrigue your user to consider what else is inside.

Path 3: Re-engagement campaign

Finally, for the third group of users who haven’t opened any of your promotional emails, you may want to set up an automated re-engagement campaign. Re-engagement email campaigns can help bring closure to both you and your unengaged users–or even save the relationship.

Don’t feel defeated when you remove unengaged recipients from your list, you’re really just polishing and perfecting your list so you can focus on your engaged customers. Plus mailbox providers like Google and Yahoo will reward you with improved inboxing rates.

Keep in mind that your own automated emails will vary on several factors including industry, email list size, and available data. The main takeaway here is to start with 1 or 2 email automations–they will go a long way to increasing your relevancy and helping you be more efficient. Finally, make sure you test and monitor your results as much as you can so you can find what works best for your email program.

Once you’ve established your goals and determined which automated email experiences will best help you achieve those goals, keep in mind the following best practice tips to ensure you’re getting the most out of automation:

Despite the tremendous potential for email automation, there are some email automation risks to consider. If you keep these risks in mind, you can fine-tune your strategy to truly reap the financial rewards of email automation:

1. Turning it “on” without testing first

Just because you’ve educated yourself and built a strategy around automating your emails, doesn’t mean you just press the send. Test a segment of your recipient list to ensure everything is working smoothly and your engagement levels hold steady or improve. If they dip, it’s time to slow down and look to see what may have been a miss.

2. Email overload

It’s easy to let your ambition take over when you’re starting to implement any new program, especially email automation. But one of the primary risks of email automation is that your recipients will get placed on too many new automated flows at once.

Your recipients may become irritated with the increased frequency (even if the content may be more targeted based on the email automation) and end up unsubscribing from your email list or marking you as spam as result. Either scenario is not good, but, fortunately, you can mitigate this risk with a little preparation.

Start your email automation program simply with only a few email flows. From there, visually map out or whiteboard your automated email workflows (also known as recipes) so you can see where there might be too much overlap.

Once you’ve started sending your first email automation, keep a close eye on your engagement. Focus your energy on your most telling engagement metrics such as open and click-through rates. If these types of metrics start to dip (how much will depend on factors such as your list size and baseline metrics), this might mean that you’ve crossed the threshold of too much sending.

Check out our Email Benchmark Report to learn about email metric benchmarks broken out by industry. And for more on finding the email-sending sweet spot, check out our Fighting Email Fatigue blog post.

3. Current events can change everything

Although automated email is often (inaccurately) referred to as “set it and forget it,” this tactic can backfire on you in some cases. Don’t forget about what you are sending and ensure that current events don’t throw off your efforts.

For example, a travel company needs to be very aware of events such as natural disasters and not send out “a screaming deal” near that location during this time as it will likely come off as insensitive (it’s happened!). Set relevant Google alerts for your industry and make monitoring news for your industry second nature so you can avoid this scenario.

4. Losing the personal touch

As you start to streamline and automate your email campaigns, there is a risk that your email content will start to lose personality. The last thing you want to do is sound like a robot to your audience.

No matter what type of email you’re sending, email content and voice are critical when you want to stand out in the inbox and get your recipients’ attention.

Spend time on email content creation. Writing to your audience and creating visuals should not be an afterthought to your campaign—it should be the focus of your workflow.

Examine your email segments and ensure that they are accurate and up to date. The more granular your segments are—for example, recipient behavior is an excellent segment to create on your list—the more relevant your content can be.

For example, you may consider going beyond just segments that divide those who rarely open your emails and those that regularly open, click, and even share your content. Maybe you have recipients that are super interested in (and click on) only promotions, while others seem to engage more with content marketing pieces.

For more on how to optimize your email segmentation, check SendGrid’s Essential Guide to Email Segmentation.

5. Forgetting to update your preference center

There is going to be a good chance that most of your recipients will receive increased emails from you once you start automating your email program (see mistake #1). If you don’t update your preference center to reflect the new campaigns, there is going to be a disconnect between your audience and your email content.

Make sure that your preference center is crystal clear and doesn’t require extra steps. The faster someone can update their preferences and modify how many emails they receive, the better. Although each preference center will look different and provide different options, make sure you’ve accounted for new flows and whether that creates a new “type of email campaign.”

Learn more about optimizing your preference center by checking out Email Preference Center Perfection. And don’t forget that even if people have filled in a preference center, you will still need to monitor their actions and whether their engagement reflects the preferences they’ve selected.